KILL THE MESSENGER SHOWS HOW TO DISCREDIT AN HONEST REPORTER
Kill The MessengerDuring 1985-1987, members of the Reagan administration persuaded Israel to sell guns to Iran in exchange for the release of Americans held hostage in Lebanon by a group connected with Iran. The United States Central Intelligence Agency then sold replacement weapons to Israel and used part of the proceeds of the sale to fund the Contras, a dissident group that sought to overthrow the democratically elected government of Nicaragua. Scenes of that Iran-Contra scandal populate the early frames of Kill the Messenger, which is about a different rogue operation that involved CIA encouragement of the Contras to fly hard drugs to Los Angeles and other American cities in order to fund their insurgency (and make millions). The latter scandal was identified by Associated Press journalists Brian Barger and Robert Parry in 1985, followed by Senator John Kerry’s investigation and report in 1989, but brushed aside by the news media until 1996, when San Jose Mercury News reporter Gary Webb (played by Jeremy Renner) broke the story based initially on grand jury testimony leaked to him by an unidentified woman. Webb, outside the major news media that had become puppets of propaganda for administrations in Washington, decided to focus on the impact on the African American community, and the result was to stir the ire of Congresswoman Maxine Waters (featured in a videotaped speech) and others that the CIA was deliberately shipping crack cocaine to the Black community. Kill the Messenger is a biopic of Webb, based on Webb’s own Dark Alliance and the biography by Nick Schou with the same title as the film. The film portrays Webb’s relentless quest to obtain secret information without a tape recorder or other means of authentication  as well as efforts of the Los Angeles TimesNew York Times, and the Washington Post to discredit him and his sources to recant, whereupon his editor (played by Oliver Platt) disavows him, forcing him to resign. The film also shows the adverse effect of his vilification on his family life, his inability to contain himself under pressure, and ends with titles indicating his death by apparent suicide in 2004 after the re-election of George W. Bush, whose entry into the Iraq War was perhaps a culmination of journalistic malfeasance that he could no longer endure. Directed by Michael Cuesta, Kill the Messenger is a quintessential exposé film and has been nominated by the Political Film Society for an award in 2014 for that category as well as best film making the case for greater democracy. MH

FURY HAS SOUND, BUT WHAT DOES IT SIGNIFY?
FuryFury, written and directed by David Ayer, is not designed as an anti-war film. Credits at the beginning note that German tanks were technically superior to American tanks, yet in the film the American tanks do better. Featured is a tank unit commanded by Don “Wardaddy” Collier (played by Brad Pitt) that is assigned to advance into Germany behind enemy lines, so there is plenty of gory battlefield action. Norman Ellison (Logan Lerman), the youngest solider, is at first afraid to shoot to kill at point blank range but later, after being mentored by Wardaddy, enjoys shooting in defense from the security of the tank. The film features a needless execution of a German soldier and rude behavior toward two young women in a home that is later destroyed for no reason. Wardaddy and his crew try to ambush an SS battalion from the tank, named Fury, despite limited ammunition. But do filmviewers really need to see another World War II film, especially with such cardboard characters? Wardaddy’s epigram “Ideals are peaceful. History is violent" may have inspired Ellison, who was snatched from a desk job to be assistant tank driver, but such a bromide underscores the depravity of the subject and thus of the film. MH

October 15, 2014

[ Previous Newsletters ] [ Other PFS Publications ]

12 Years a Slave
42
2016
A Dark Truth
Aftermath
After the Wizard
Age of Uprising
All God's Children
Arbitrage
The Angel's Share
Argo
Bethlehem
Big Miracle
The Book Thief
Boys of Abu Ghraib
Broken City
Burning Blue
The Butler
The Campaign
Capital
Captain Phillips
Cesar Chavez
China Heavyweight
A Coffee in Berlin
The Company You
Keep

Coldwater
Compliance
Dallas Buyers Club
Dawn of the Planet of the Apes
Declaration of War
Devil's Knot
The Dictator
Divergent
Dormant Beauty
Elysium
The Emperor
Farewell, My Queen
The Fifth Estate
For Greater Glory
Fort McCoy
Frontera
Fruitvale Station
Fury
Gangster Squad
Generation P
Geography Club
The Giver
Go For Sisters
Hunger Games: Catching Fire
Hyde Park on Hudson
Ilo Ilo
The Immigrant
Kill The Messenger
Kill Your Darlings
Knife Fight
The Last Sentence
Leonie
Legends of Oz
The Liberator
Lincoln
The Lone Ranger
Love is Strange
Lula, Son of Brazil
Lullaby
Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom
The Master
Miss Bala
The Monuments Men
A Most Wanted Man
Mulberry Child
Nebraska
Night Moves
No
Omar
Out in the Dark
Oz: The Great and Powerful
Parkland
Philomena
Policeman
Polisse
Pride
Promised Land
The Railway Man
Red Tails
The Reluctant Fundamentalist
The Retrieval
Rio 2096
A River Changes Course
A Royal Affair
Sacrifice
Saving Lincoln
The Secret Life of Walter Mitty
Siddharth
Side Effects
A Touch of Sin (Tian zhu ding)
Trade of Innocents
Transcendence
W./E.
Wadjda
Walking with the Enemy
War of the Buttons
West of Thunder
White House Down
The Wolf of Wall Street
Won't Back Down
Zaytoun
Zero Dark Thirty



NOMINATED FILMS
FOR 2014
(click on a title to read
a PFS review)

DEMOCRACY
Cesar Chavez

EXPOSÉ
Bethlehem
Cesar Chavez
Coldwater
The Last Sentence
The Monuments Men
Omar
Pride
The Railway Man
Siddharth
Walking with the Enemy

HUMAN RIGHTS
Bethlehem
Cesar Chavez
Coldwater
Devil's Knot
The Monuments Men
Pride
The Railway Man
Siddharth
Walking with the Enemy

PEACE
Cesar Chavez
The Railway Man

Click here to nominate a film






winner of the 1999
Political Site Of The Day

 

 
  Home | To Join PFS | Essays on Film | Previous Winners | Nominate a Film | Links: Film Reviews | Contact PFS  

copyright © 2014 Political Film Society. All Rights Reserved.
Design by
Last updated: October 17, 2014